Berlin Suspends Ratification of the Lisbon Treaty

Berlin Suspends its Ratification of the Lisbon Treaty

by Bruno Odent, Spectrezine, July 8, 2009

Germany. The Constitutional Court objects to failures of democracy in the European text, in particular, with respect to transport and national laws.

A surprising new obstacle has arisen in the process of ratification of the Lisbon Treaty: the German Constitutional Court announced at the end of June that it is suspending the German ratification of the treaty, adopted several months ago by the parliamentary route, until an accompanying law preserving the rights of the Bundestag and Bundesrat - the two houses of the German federal parliament - can be promulgated.

Acting on a complaint registered by the deputies of Germany's most left parliamentary party Die Linke on the one hand, and by the right wing Euro-sceptics on the other, the court decided that the treaty was certainly "compatible" with the constitution, but added that its adoption must be conditioned by a new arsenal of national law designed to prevent Brussels from trampling on citizens' rights. In other words, if the judges toward whom the watchful eyes of the European "elites" had been turned have not condemned the text, they have at least expressed the need to constrain it seriously in order to preserve the rights of citizens.

The decision illustrates once more the deficiencies of democracy in the European text, the deficiencies that were the chief reasons for its rejection at each attempt for ratification these past four years. After the unproductive presentation of the European Constitution, carving in granite the laws of neo-liberalism, rejected in the French and Dutch referenda, its clone adopted in Lisbon has likewise been subjected to a veritable obstacle course. Its future depends, as we all know, on the outcome of the Irish referendum, where the Irish people have been asked to vote again in autumn, having already once said "No".

The decision by the judges in Karlsruhe, which is the seat of the Constitutional Court, could not be more specific. It emphasizes that because of a "deficit of structural democracy" at the level of the European Union (EU), the rights of co-decision by the German parliament must be clearly stated in law. In the opinion of the court, this will be the only way to "guarantee the effectiveness of the right to vote" for German citizens, and to "keep an eye out" that the EU "does not stray outside the competences it has been granted".

The starting gun for a foot race has been fired in Berlin, that the accompanying law demanded by the Constitutional Court be drafted and passed by the Bundestag as quickly as possible. The parties of the grand coalition (the centre-left CDU and centre-right SPD) have held emergency meetings, and the Chancellor Angela Merkel has quickly announced that the Bundestag will be asked to interrupt its summer vacation, to meet on 26 August to begin the process of ratification of the law, which must be promulgated by 8 September at the latest. The smallest new detail can thus have a calamitous effect on the ratification process in Ireland and elsewhere. It may well also have an effect on the legislative elections planned in Germany for the end of September.

Despite the very large majority in the hands of the CDU and SPD, it is not impossible that this hurried process of ratification will arouse strong reactions in public opinion. According to recent polls, a huge majority of citizens (70% to 85% of persons polled) continue to ask for a referendum on the subject, a referendum the outcome of which seems very uncertain. The organization of a popular consultation would be the only way, according to Die Linke, to restore its "lost legitimacy" to the process of ratification. It is not clear that this debate will not interfere with the legislative campaigns. And this, as they observe from the headquarters of Die Linke in Berlin, is not the sort of thing to be very reassuring to "the parties to the neo-liberal concensus".

The original article in French was published in L'Humanité. This translation by Henry Crapo was first published on the paper's English-language website