The Code of Capital: How the Law Creates Wealth and Inequality

⚖️

The Code of Capital: How the Law Creates Wealth and Inequality

Katharina Pistor's The Code of Capital examines how law shapes wealth and inequality globally. The book argues that law, specifically private law, is the fundamental mechanism creating and distributing wealth, not just markets. Pistor traces the historical evolution of legal tools—like property rights, contracts, and corporate structures—showing how they've been used to create and protect capital, often at the expense of broader societal well-being. She further explores how these legal tools are used in different contexts, from land ownership to modern financial instruments, illustrating the power of legal coding in shaping global capitalism. Finally, the book considers the implications of this system, including questions of access, inequality, and the potential role of digital technologies in reshaping the future of capital.

Briefing Document: The Code of Capital - Key Themes and Ideas

I. Overview

Pistor's work explores how law actively creates capital, rather than simply regulating existing wealth. It argues that legal codes are the essential “software” of capitalism, and that by understanding how these codes work, we can see the mechanisms that generate both wealth and inequality. The book examines how legal systems transform assets (tangible or intangible) into capital via a process of coding, which involves giving them legal attributes that enhance their value and enable them to be used as collateral or traded more efficiently.

II. Key Themes & Concepts

• The "Code of Capital": The central idea is that capital is not a natural or pre-existing thing, but rather a legal construct. "Assets are not 'capital' until they are legally coded." (Implied). This coding involves using legal tools to imbue assets with specific attributes that enable them to be used in capitalist transactions. This includes things like legal personhood, property rights, priority in bankruptcy, and transferability.
• 
  
• Legal Modules: Pistor describes the law as made up of "modules" that can be recombined and adapted. These modules, like trust law, contract law, or corporate law, can be adjusted or applied to new kinds of assets to make them into capital. The excerpt notes: "Most of the time, the boundaries of the code’s modules are pushed slowly, step by step. If a legal module, such as the trust, can be used to harbor land and thereby protect it from creditors, perhaps it can protect other assets as well…" This suggests that legal innovation constantly extends the scope of what can be capitalized.
• 
  
• Intangible Capital: A significant focus is on how law creates intangible capital, such as intellectual property, financial instruments, and even digital assets. Pistor emphasizes that these are "creatures of the law" and argues that they may be even more "footloose" than physical property because they don't always require formal state action to come into being: "If anything, financial assets may be even more footloose than intellectual property rights, because they do not need an official act of state to come into existence."
• 
  
• Asset Shielding: A recurring theme is how legal coding allows for the shielding of assets from risk and creditors. This is achieved through mechanisms like trusts, corporate veils, and bankruptcy safe harbors. The book shows how these mechanisms aren't just neutral features, but powerful tools for concentrating wealth and power.
• 
  
• The Role of Lawyers: Lawyers are not just passive interpreters of the law but are active participants in constructing and adapting the legal code: "They are coded in the modules of the code of capital, over which lawyers have much sway subject only to the odd challenge in a court of law." The excerpt stresses lawyers’ ability to choose from various legal systems to achieve the best outcome for their clients. Pistor calls lawyers the “code masters” who are shaping global finance and the modern world.
• 
  
• Bankruptcy as a Political Act: Bankruptcy law is highlighted as a crucial area where political choices determine the allocation of losses. The excerpt states, "The reason is that bankruptcy law is the place where losses are realized and allocated, which is inherently a political task." It acts as a stress test for property rights, influencing behavior "ex ante" based on how it allocates claims in times of default.
• 
  
• Global Derivatives Markets: The excerpt describes how legal structures have been modified and extended to support global derivatives markets. Legal innovations have allowed for the safe harboring of complex derivatives in bankruptcy, which facilitates these markets, but potentially at the cost of other creditors. "This legal metamorphosis occurred from 1978 to 2005. In addition, if any man- made discovery or invention can be protected by patent, why not push patent authorities to recognize even the smallest alteration of nature’s code as such an innovation?"
• 
  
• Bitcoin and Private Money: Bitcoin is presented as a departure from conventional forms of private money because of its design as "money without credit." "Bitcoin is designed as money without credit: nobody can spend Bitcoin without proof of owner-ship." This characteristic, according to Pistor, challenges a core feature of capitalism, which relies on the ability to spend money one does not yet possess. It's used as a contrasting example of how digital money and legal code interact.
• 
  
• State Power & International Law: The book highlights the role of the state in creating and enforcing the legal code of capital, but also how the power of the state is often limited by international law. The excerpt uses the Metalclad case as an example of how a state can be held liable under international law for actions taken by its sub-units, even if these actions are not within the control of the central government.
• 
  
• Evolution of Law: The book shows that laws change over time, they are not static, and are often modified incrementally to meet the needs of those who are positioned to benefit from these modifications, such as elites and lawyers. "Most of the time, the boundaries of the code’s modules are pushed slowly, step by step."

III. Important Facts

• Metalclad Case: A specific legal case where Mexico was held liable under international law for a municipality's refusal to grant a license, showcasing how international law can limit states’ internal authority.
• 
  
• The expansion of patent law: The US Supreme court decision in 1980 which allowed for parts of nature’s code to be patentable is used as a prime example of how the legal code surrounding patent law is constantly being expanded through legal action.
• 
  
• Derivatives and the Financial Crisis: The text implies that the expansion of derivatives markets through legal innovation is one of the reasons why the 2008 financial crisis happened.
• 
  
• Bitcoin as "Money without Credit": Bitcoin’s design as a system where users cannot spend what they don’t have is viewed as a departure from the typical function of money under capitalism.

IV. Implications

• Wealth and Inequality: The book implies that the legal codes themselves are a major driver of wealth concentration. By manipulating the code, some can accrue more advantages and wealth over others. "This gives you the history of trust law in a nutshell, from its feudal origins to modern- day shadow banking."
• 
  
• Challenges to State Sovereignty: International legal obligations and private codes are shown to constrain the power of states.
• 
  
• The Need for Legal Reform: The book implicitly calls for greater scrutiny and potential reform of legal codes that create capital. This could include mechanisms to restrict the shielding of assets, allocate losses more fairly in bankruptcy, and regulate the creation and trading of complex financial instruments.

V. Conclusion

Pistor’s "The Code of Capital" provides a powerful framework for understanding the relationship between law, wealth, and inequality. It argues that the legal code is not a neutral instrument but an active force that shapes economic outcomes. By demystifying the legal mechanisms that create capital, the book offers a critical perspective on the architecture of capitalism and its distributional effects.

Timeline of Main Events

• Feudal Era to Early Modern Times:Development of trust law, initially to harbor land and protect it from creditors. (This period is not given a specific date range in the text)
• Early forms of private money, like bills of exchange, begin to emerge.
• 
  
• 17th - 19th CenturiesEnclosure Acts in England privatize land use, turning it into a commodity.
• The rise of industrial policy, with governments giving out monopolies to stimulate invention, but also to favor certain industry.
• 
  
• Development of corporate structures with limited liability.
• The emergence of a sophisticated merchant class, building on the older feudal structures.
• Development of legal doctrines such as "Discovery Doctrine", which justified land seizures from indigenous populations.
• 
  
• 19th Century:Emergence of modern forms of property rights and debt.
• The expansion of securitization practices.
• 
  
• Late 19th Century:The use of the trust as a legal instrument for asset protection evolves from its feudal origins to protect other forms of wealth, not just land, and to manage pooled assets.
• 
  
• Early 20th Century:Rise of the large industrial corporations in the US, and the modern legal structures around them.
• 
  
• 1978-2005:A significant legal metamorphosis occurs, extending bankruptcy safe harbors to swaps and other derivatives of private assets.
• Global lobbying efforts to create conditions for global derivatives markets.
• 
  
• 1980:The US Supreme Court asserts that parts of nature's code are patentable, opening the door for biotech companies to stake claims on genetic material.
• 
  
• Late 20th Century to Early 21st Century:Explosion of the derivatives market, with complex financial instruments like CDOs becoming common.
• Growth of regulatory arbitrage facilitated by legal structures and globalization.
• The securitization of mortgages transforms real estate debt into tradable securities.
• 
  
• 2008:The Global Financial Crisis, triggered by the collapse of Lehman Brothers, highlights the systemic risk of complex financial instruments like derivatives and mortgage-backed securities.
• 
  
• 2016:The DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization) hack shows the vulnerabilities of smart contracts and digital code.
• 
  
• Post-2008:Ongoing legal battles regarding the scope of patents, especially involving genetic material.
• Development and proliferation of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin.
• 
  

Cast of Characters

• Satoshi Nakamoto: The pseudonymous creator of Bitcoin, who published the "Bitcoin Manifesto," aiming to solve the double-spending problem.
• Richard Fuld: CEO of Lehman Brothers, whose actions and policies led to its downfall in 2008.
• William Blackstone: 18th-century English jurist, whose Commentaries on the Laws of England was highly influential on the development of common law in England and the US.
• Adam Smith: Scottish economist and philosopher (1723-1790), whose concept of the "invisible hand" is referenced in the context of market mechanisms and self-interest.
• Karl Marx: 19th-century German philosopher and economist, whose theories on capitalism, labor, and class are contrasted in the context of law's role in economic inequality.
• Friedrich Engels: Collaborator of Marx, co-author of The Communist Manifesto, and whose theories on social evolution is referenced here.
• Gregor Mendel: 19th-century Austrian scientist, whose work on genetics is cited in the discussion of intellectual property and nature's code.
• James Watson & Francis Crick: Scientists who co-discovered the structure of DNA in the 1950s, work used as a reference point for the discussion on nature's code and patentability.
• Nick Szabo: A computer scientist, referenced for his work on digital contracts and the concept of "code is law."
• Thurgood Marshall: US Supreme Court Justice, who delivered the opinion in the Johnson v. M'Intosh case.
• Hernando De Soto: Economist who writes about the link between property law and capital, but is not directly referenced in these excerpts.
• Louis Brandeis: US Supreme Court Justice known for his work on corporate and anti-trust law.
• Ronald Coase: Economist, associated with the concept of "transaction cost economics," which this text engages with.
• Stephen Magee: A scholar associated with the study of lawyers as "code masters."
• Christopher Columbus Langdell: A 19th century Dean of Harvard Law School who advocated a case-based approach to legal education.
• Alan Greenspan: Former head of the US Federal Reserve, who was a strong proponent of deregulation and is often associated with the lead-up to the 2008 crash.
• Hyman P. Minsky: Economist known for his work on financial instability and "Minsky Moments," often connected with the dynamics of financial booms and crashes.
• Robert Merton & Myron Scholes: Economists who won a Nobel Prize for their work on option pricing, often associated with the theory underpinning derivatives.
• Joseph Schumpeter: 20th century economist who developed the concept of "creative destruction".
• Christoph Menke: Philosopher, whose Critique of Rights is referenced in the context of the legal underpinnings of capitalist power.
• 
  

Key Themes & Concepts

Throughout the timeline and character list, several key themes and concepts emerge:

• The Law as a Code: The text emphasizes that the law is not merely a set of rules but a "code" that structures economic relations, particularly in creating and enforcing property rights and debts.
• Intangible Capital: Much of the analysis focuses on "intangible assets" such as intellectual property, financial derivatives, and other legal constructs. The text shows how these assets can generate enormous wealth, but also contribute to instability and inequality.
• Legal Innovation & Regulatory Arbitrage: The timeline highlights the constant innovation in legal structures to protect and expand capital and the means by which those structures circumvent regulation.
• Globalization & Legal Harmonization: The emergence of a global code, promoted by international organizations, law firms, and the financial industry, is a key theme.
• The Role of Lawyers: Lawyers are presented not just as interpreters of the law, but as active "code masters" who can shape legal structures to the advantage of their clients.
• The Tension Between Private & Public Power: The text reveals the continuous struggle between private economic interests and state power, with states often creating structures that favor private interests.
• Inequality & Exclusion: The code of capital, despite its capacity to generate wealth, is shown to create and exacerbate economic inequality.
• The Fragility of Modern Finance: The text points out how complex financial instruments and legal constructs have created systemically risky markets.